Mister Rogers’ Peanut Butter Sandwich
In 1993, my grandmother captured this recipe from episode 1612 of Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood, in which Mr. McFeely makes his “McFeely Family Snack” to share with Mister Rogers. They put it over rice cakes, but we were more of a sandwich family.
Ingredients:
1/3 cup dry milk
1 cup apple butter
1 cup peanut butter
Choice: Your favorite bread, crackers, rice cakes, a tortilla… whatever you’d like to eat.
Instructions:
In an airtight container, combine the dry milk, apple butter, and peanut butter until well mixed.
Spread an even layer between two slices of bread, on crackers, or over a rice cake. (I wouldn’t blame you if you eat this with a spoon, though.)
Notes:
Dry milk and apple butter can be tough to find these days. We always got ours at Aldi’s, though I’m not sure they carry either ingredient anymore.
We love a recipe blog that gets right to the point. That’s why we never insert off-site ads (or ridiculously long stories) in any of our recipes. To help support Recipes Kept and Little Acre Homestead, please subscribe to our Patreon!
